Song Review Archive

  • “I John” is Elvis gospel at its most propulsive.  The feel is sweaty, churchy—body music animated with the spirit of the Lord.  “Baby, Let’s Play House” may be the Hillbilly […]

    Elvis Presley – I John

    “I John” is Elvis gospel at its most propulsive.  The feel is sweaty, churchy—body music animated with the spirit of the Lord.  “Baby, Let’s Play House” may be the Hillbilly […]

    Continue Reading...

  • You come home to someone who had waited.  You guys aren’t close now.  You’re strangers. You go outside for a walk.  It’s good to be home, but you can’t shake […]

    LCD Soundsystem – All I Want

    You come home to someone who had waited.  You guys aren’t close now.  You’re strangers. You go outside for a walk.  It’s good to be home, but you can’t shake […]

    Continue Reading...

  • The Kinks katalog is full of sidebars that other bands would kill to have written.  Commissioned for a film about a penis transplant, “The Way Love Used to Be” is one […]

    The Kinks – The Way Love Used To Be

    The Kinks katalog is full of sidebars that other bands would kill to have written.  Commissioned for a film about a penis transplant, “The Way Love Used to Be” is one […]

    Continue Reading...

  • Solo Paul McCartney is full of crap.  As folks have remarked for longer than I’ve been alive, his music from 1971 on misses the Beatles.  It is no match for […]

    Paul McCartney – Zoo Gang

    Solo Paul McCartney is full of crap.  As folks have remarked for longer than I’ve been alive, his music from 1971 on misses the Beatles.  It is no match for […]

    Continue Reading...

  • Stevie Nicks has said that “Sara” is about the doomed affair she had with her best friend’s husband — who just so happened to be Mick Fleetwood, her own drummer. […]

    Fleetwood Mac – Sara

    Stevie Nicks has said that “Sara” is about the doomed affair she had with her best friend’s husband — who just so happened to be Mick Fleetwood, her own drummer. […]

    Continue Reading...

  • Sometimes the greatness of a song lies not so much in the melody and lyrics, or even the resolution thereof, but the absence, perhaps the deliberate exclusion of these things.  […]

    Nirvana – Scentless Apprentice

    Sometimes the greatness of a song lies not so much in the melody and lyrics, or even the resolution thereof, but the absence, perhaps the deliberate exclusion of these things.  […]

    Continue Reading...

  • Would you call this a work of art? Far from the love-me-goo of the Beatles’ shtick, pre-’65, and quickly overdubbed in the twilight of their studio-bound seclusion, “Old Brown Shoe” […]

    The Beatles – Old Brown Shoe

    Would you call this a work of art? Far from the love-me-goo of the Beatles’ shtick, pre-’65, and quickly overdubbed in the twilight of their studio-bound seclusion, “Old Brown Shoe” […]

    Continue Reading...

  • Co-written and produced by David Bowie, Iggy Pop’s “Baby” is a sketch.  It’s drum-less and tight — a model of almost James M. Cain-like restraint.  No less direct than the […]

    Iggy Pop – Baby

    Co-written and produced by David Bowie, Iggy Pop’s “Baby” is a sketch.  It’s drum-less and tight — a model of almost James M. Cain-like restraint.  No less direct than the […]

    Continue Reading...

  • A dirge for River Phoenix. R.E.M. is here: the skew, the melody, the jangle. But it’s different; it’s Wagnerian, unlike (and better than) anything else they did. As Patti Smith […]

    R.E.M. – E-Bow The Letter

    A dirge for River Phoenix. R.E.M. is here: the skew, the melody, the jangle. But it’s different; it’s Wagnerian, unlike (and better than) anything else they did. As Patti Smith […]

    Continue Reading...

  • A brave face on a breakup, before and after. His guitar weighs his loneliness.

    Peter Frampton – Lines On My Face

    A brave face on a breakup, before and after. His guitar weighs his loneliness.

    Continue Reading...